Yes, it doesn’t either go away or get better. There is more bad news coming from Equitable Life, and all because of those guaranteed annuity rates they offered all those years ago. Their reported excess assets have fallen by a third.
Their measure of financial strength fell by a third in 2008 as the society, which closed to new business some eight years ago, was hit by the combined ‘double whammy’ of falling asset prices and rising bond yields. Mind you, nothing compared to the suffering faced by their many annuity planholders.
Equitable Life revealed that its excess realistic assets over liabilities fell around £207 million to £414 million last year. In preliminary annual results it noted considerable uncertainty over the future but remained confident that its finances were ‘sound’ and that it remains a ‘going concern’. We sincerely hope this is the case for this troubled pension annuity provider.
The society’s biggest concern as it proceeds into winding down the business is expenses. As its £6 billion with-profits fund diminishes the proportion of fixed costs will rise. It is in talks with a number of external third party administrators about entering into a long-term contract. It also indicated it was looking to organise another restructure and shed even more staff.
The with profits fund suffered a net investment loss of 7.7% last year after costs of administration and guarantees (those guaranteed annuity rates again), following a 1.8% return in the previous year. It cut planholders values by around 2% last month, after a slightly bigger cut was made in December. The combined effect of these two cuts wiped out the gains made in 2007.
Equitable guarantees a minimum annual investment return of 3.5% for the majority of its policyholders. The cost of this went up from £814 million from £442 million. Guarantees are an extremely sore topic for Equitable. It was the cost of guaranteed annuity rates, which the Lords forced Equitable to honour, that crippled it in 1999 and led to its closure the following year.
The outgoing chief executive stated that with careful management it continues to ride out the most challenging of financial conditions, and it continues to look for the best outcomes for policyholders, adding that progress is being made with negotiations for a long-term administration agreement which will offer some expense security for the future.


